Why don't you give feedback ?

did · Post by **did** » Sun May 17, 2009 1:58 pm

Why don't you post feedback?

Cus I'm 1337

jackw · Post by **jackw** » Sun May 17, 2009 2:28 pm

sollabong wrote:dubs forum is about(as i see) to suck each others coks...drop bigups...i think these posts are useless...sorry about my opinion..and i know its not an answer to your question

F**K EMPTY CONVERSATIONS!!!

i think it may help the producer to know if his work is loved, but sure, we all like to recieve bigups =p

jackw · Post by **jackw** » Sun May 17, 2009 2:32 pm

slight wrote:I think there's a big difference between not liking something and thinking aspects of it could do with improvement.

Obviously it's always nice if someone says they like your tune, especially if you think they mean it, but I think most people are looking for constructive criticism, which is amazingly hard to find, especially from friends.

Useful things you can comment on about someone's tune, especially if you do production yourself:

- Programming
- Mix (especially this, as having people listen on other equipment can be very useful feedback)
- Sounds (drum sounds, synths, vocals, fx)
- Arrangement (this is something I personally suck at so I always like to hear suggestions on my arrangements

Really "that's great" and "that sucks" are useless information. If you can pick out something specific it's going to be much more useful to people. Whether you subjectively like a track overall is neither here nor there, because people's tastes are so different.

thanks

abs · Post by **abs** » Sun May 17, 2009 3:05 pm

i don't comment because 99% of it is shit, it's also annoying having to go to someones myspace page and wait ages for everything to load up.. if a tune is actually good i'll usually send the producer a little pm saying 'well done mate, give me 320 now'

Hibbie · Post by **Hibbie** » Sun May 17, 2009 8:08 pm

Abs wrote:i don't comment because 99% of it is shit, it's also annoying having to go to someones myspace page and wait ages for everything to load up.. if a tune is actually good i'll usually send the producer a little pm saying 'well done mate, give me 320 now'

haha, at least your honest

expo · Post by **expo** » Mon May 18, 2009 11:25 am

Abs wrote:i don't comment because 99% of it is shit

Come on, don't exaggerate...only 98% shit.
Plus many posters are now blowins that don't contribute to the communal ongoing discourse before dumping their creations upon it....the done-and-dusted commodification of ds is now a swamp.

d+ · Post by d+ » Mon May 18, 2009 12:13 pm

dubs section is a hive of festering crap, sry peeps

cookiemonsta · Post by **cookiemonsta** » Tue May 19, 2009 9:05 am

JackW wrote:Hi dubstepperz

just a question in the air ;p ::
why don't you give feedback on the dubstep dubz?
coz you don't have time to,
coz you don't like ?
coz you think all that subforum tunes are shit ?
coz you're more than us ;P
coz you want to act like cookie m*nsta :p

just find a reason (if you have time to ;D) & check my new tune @ http://www.myspace.com/jackwp

peace & don't forget that i'm in love with stella ;p

Alrite fella,

The only reason why i find it difficult to message back people is the fact that i have no internet, i get small chances when im at college, i tried to message everyone but i obviously cannot sometimes if i am literally unable to...

Sorry for any inconvienience matey.....

SickMan D · Post by **SickMan D** » Tue May 19, 2009 1:24 pm

I leave it when I like the tune but I dont spend much time in there anymore, most the time I only check out the remix's... Kelly Dean & The Widdler kill it every time!

Pistonsbeneath · Post by **Pistonsbeneath** » Tue May 19, 2009 1:44 pm

they're rarely worth listening to i've found to be honest

Why don't you give feedback ?

Re: Why don't you give feedback ?

Who is online