Iv run out of patience with the feedback thread.

[Dystinkt]

Iv posted 2 or 3 wips in there, after giving reasonable feedback to the required 3 people, but i got immensely shitty replies from everyone else or none at all. dicks.

[fragments]

I've *always* found it more useful to develop a network of people to exchange critiques with whether it's music, writing whatever the medium than relying on an internet forum.

I think it's possible to get a good critique here, just less likely than with a small peer group.

[DZA]

[hasezwei]

feedback forum > feedback thread
srs

[deadly_habit]

feedback forum > feedback thread
srs

why i was all for the wip thread being moved there, but too many people bitched and it clung on here like a piece of toilet paper after a nasty shit

[hudson]

feedback forum > feedback thread
srs

I've never once gotten a reply from the feedback forum, but I always get good stuff in the thread.

[Basic A]

Im sick of everyone running around giving production advice/feedback, I just want simple 'yeah I like this' 'no I dont like this' stuff...

Trade with one of you guys, c'mon...

[-[2]DAY_-]

i been sayin' it and sayin' it.

just use Dubs for what it's meant for, and to the general ProFo populace: GO TO DUBS and BUMP the SHIT out of one another's tunes.
People who frequent the profo just happen to usually make better tunes (hmmm) and ought to help one another's threads stay relevant instead of being burried by MY FIRST DUBSTEP __ FILTHY S#**!!!! threads

WIP or not, tbh it ought to be finished, but after the forum listens and discusses, the tune could be reworked and reposted (continuing to bump their worthwhile thread with a refix)

i've seen more of it lately than i used to, but DUBS ought to be the profo'er's feedback haven. Until someday, some of us graduate to "Music (tunes and releases)"

[hutyluty]

Yeah man Dubs is where its at trust- with no money its how im keepiung my music collection expanding brap

Until someday, some of us graduate to "Music (tunes and releases)"

one day my friend.... one day

[paravrais]

Until someday, some of us graduate to "Music (tunes and releases)"

one day my friend.... one day

Haha XD


And OP, make better tunes and you'll get better feedback. That's the trend that I see both in the feedback thread and the dubs forum.

For reals though, don't make another thread like this. Nobody cares.

[nnny]

@OP followed you on SC, when I see a new WIP ill try my best to give you some feedback <3

[eb4evr]

Currently on a cr-48 google laptop, but i'll check your stuff when i get some headphones.

i think it'd be cool to make a soundcloud group for posting WIP's to be commented on or whatever with a group of people who actually take the time to listen to other people's stuff

[hudson]

Currently on a cr-48 google laptop, but i'll check your stuff when i get some headphones.

i think it'd be cool to make a soundcloud group for posting WIP's to be commented on or whatever with a group of people who actually take the time to listen to other people's stuff

That's actually a cool idea. It would really help with the clutter in the thread.

[eb4evr]

http://soundcloud.com/groups/dubstep-fo ... ck/dropbox

obviously it'll take a bit to get built up but it's worth a shot..

[Dystinkt]

im down for that eb4evr. thanks nnny for giving my stuff a listen, the feedback thread just gives me nothing to take forward from my tunes at all.

[eb4evr]

im down for that eb4evr. thanks nnny for giving my stuff a listen, the feedback thread just gives me nothing to take forward from my tunes at all.

share it to the group i just put one of my tracks down

[secret door]

I thought OP was calling the band LV dicks for not replying to a song s/he sent them or something.

[Kes-Es]

Until someday, some of us graduate to "Music (tunes and releases)"

one day my friend.... one day

Haha XD


And OP, make better tunes and you'll get better feedback. That's the trend that I see both in the feedback thread and the dubs forum.

For reals though, don't make another thread like this. Nobody cares.

I must be making shit tunes,



Anytime I post a thread in there I'm lucky to get a response, and when I do it's not really constructive. Even in the small network of people I send tunes to and soundcloud it's very rarely constructive, nice at least though.

[Augment]

Until someday, some of us graduate to "Music (tunes and releases)"

one day my friend.... one day

Haha XD


And OP, make better tunes and you'll get better feedback. That's the trend that I see both in the feedback thread and the dubs forum.

For reals though, don't make another thread like this. Nobody cares.

I must be making shit tunes,



Anytime I post a thread in there I'm lucky to get a response, and when I do it's not really constructive. Even in the small network of people I send tunes to and soundcloud it's very rarely constructive, nice at least though.

dude, your tunes are SICK
But on topic, yeah you should definetely build up a small network of producers willing to give feedback.

[hudson]

I must be making shit tunes,



Anytime I post a thread in there I'm lucky to get a response, and when I do it's not really constructive. Even in the small network of people I send tunes to and soundcloud it's very rarely constructive, nice at least though.

That's how I feel too. The Dubs forum is where my new-track-excitement goes to die. I've never gotten a single reply there and I've posted at least three songs. If it is a question of quality, then that makes it even worse. What's the point of having a thread and a forum for feedback if the people who actually need it aren't getting it? But yeah, it really makes me feel like I'm not even good enough to be told I'm not good.