1stfiest wrote:Why i might go for the KRK KNS 8400, as opposed to Beyerdynamic DT770, Shure SRH 840, AKG K550 or AT M50.
Beyer DT770
This graph shows a very bright sounding top end with over exaggerated lows. This could result in some interesting sounding mixes, but i feel they are going to be too sensitive to bass orientated music. The mid's are looking quite good, with an interesting dip at 5khz. Overall, mixing on such brightly coloured headphones is a huge put-off overall.
Shure SRH840
Bass cutoff at 50hz is quite unappealing, as i don't have a sub, i will be using headphones as my main bass reference. Very strong mid's, which means if you listen to anything that has been mixed on a "flat" system, the mid's are going to come across very shouty and in your face.
ATH M50
Scarily similar to the Beyerdynamics above, Bright top end and over exaggerated bass response, mid's are looking quite strong, giving them the shouty effect that the Shure SRH840's do.
AKG K550
Again, we are looking at a over exaggerated bass response, but really shallow high's. Which is unfortunate as this pair looks like it might have a really sweet sounding mid.
Finally, KRK KNS 8400
Here we have something a bit different to all the others, which is a strong bass response from 50-30hz, giving you a great definition for sub referencing. The high's are not over exagerated and the shallow dips at 5k is really going to give your music room to breathe. Another really interesting aspect of these headphones, is the dipped mids, as opposed to them being boosted and shouty, like all the other headphones.
In the past week, i have been fortunate to wear a couple of these headphones.
The SHURE SRH840's and the KRK KNS 8400's.
This, backed with what i can interoperate from the frequency response graphs, is what is shaping my decision.
The Shures and the KRKs are complete opposites in terms of there response in the mids. One being shouty and "in your face", and the other being dipped and slightly "pushed back". Now, if i am planning to listen and work on a project for hours on end, i don't want headphones that are going to be too shouty, too bright sounding, too over-exaggerated in any area. Something subtle and rather flat is preferred, this way I will enjoy the experience more, and spend more time enjoying production. Which, tbh, is what i'm after. Somewhat more of an audiophile opinion than that of a producer maybe? Or maybe the other way round, I can't really say.
Fortunately next week i will get a chance to listen in on some Beyerdynamic DT770's, which will also form my final opinion of the ATH M50's as they are very similar in terms of frequency response. My only regret, is that i won't have a chance to try the AKG K550's, which look like a really interesting "bass orientated" pair of headphones.