Page 4 of 6
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 5:31 pm
by legend4ry
My favourite albums are usually those cult ones what hardly got success when they came out. That makes me sound so hipster but I think the best albums are those only musicians, producers and genuine music lovers (not admirers) can enjoy...
A great album is one where it enthuses the mood you're in and encapsulates you. For instance I can't listen to Portishead - Portishead or Jeff Buckley - Grace, without it having some sort of emotional affect on me.. Be it happy or sad! Great music seems to capture something within a person, even if its some brostep and it makes someone go absolutely bro-tastic, it still must be great music if its having an affect on people, right?
Its an interesting discussion I think personally..
And to the person who said theres not a lot of Electronic music being posted here...
Thats because most electronic albums are not perfect - they generally are a collection of the artists tracks which fit within a time frame of being made, opposed to themes and one main inspiration.. (my personal opinion).
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 5:37 pm
by paravrais
Kodachrome wrote:- 1 for coldplay, - 10 million for coldplay with no radiohead.
Also +1000000 for the always open mouth <3
I knew I'd get hate for that but I don't give a shit

The thing with radiohead is that, whilst they have made a lot more consistantly amazing music than Coldplay, they don't have any one album that really stands out to me as being perfect the way Parachutes does. They come close but not quite.
Parachutes is one of the best albums ever made and anyone who doesn't agree with that is either deaf, hasn't actually listened to it or is so obsessed with being 'cool' and 'alternative' that they refuse to allow themselves to like anything that's broadly considered pop music
[I'm guessing you fit into categories 2 and 3 there...]
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 5:38 pm
by legend4ry
Parachutes is a great album, no denying it.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 5:41 pm
by paravrais
legend4ry wrote:My favourite albums are usually those cult ones what hardly got success when they came out. That makes me sound so hipster but I think the best albums are those only musicians, producers and genuine music lovers (not admirers) can enjoy...
A great album is one where it enthuses the mood you're in and encapsulates you. For instance I can't listen to Portishead - Portishead or Jeff Buckley - Grace, without it having some sort of emotional affect on me.. Be it happy or sad! Great music seems to capture something within a person, even if its some brostep and it makes someone go absolutely bro-tastic, it still must be great music if its having an affect on people, right?
I love how you talk about cult music and then mention two of the biggest names in music ever XD Your point is valid though to a degree, generally the chart topping stuff is less thoughtful and lovingly crafted than underground stuff. Doesn't mean you don't get the odd chart topper that's as good, if not better than the underground stuff. Though this is becoming increasingly rare
EDIT: In fact I think over the last decade it's become pretty much unheard of. In the 90's there were amazing artists topping the charts...I can't think of more than maybe 2 in the whole last decade that were of the same standard.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 5:44 pm
by -[2]DAY_-
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 5:57 pm
by legend4ry
paravrais wrote:legend4ry wrote:My favourite albums are usually those cult ones what hardly got success when they came out. That makes me sound so hipster but I think the best albums are those only musicians, producers and genuine music lovers (not admirers) can enjoy...
A great album is one where it enthuses the mood you're in and encapsulates you. For instance I can't listen to Portishead - Portishead or Jeff Buckley - Grace, without it having some sort of emotional affect on me.. Be it happy or sad! Great music seems to capture something within a person, even if its some brostep and it makes someone go absolutely bro-tastic, it still must be great music if its having an affect on people, right?
I love how you talk about cult music and then mention two of the biggest names in music ever XD Your point is valid though to a degree, generally the chart topping stuff is less thoughtful and lovingly crafted than underground stuff. Doesn't mean you don't get the odd chart topper that's as good, if not better than the underground stuff. Though this is becoming increasingly rare
EDIT: In fact I think over the last decade it's become pretty much unheard of. In the 90's there were amazing artists topping the charts...I can't think of more than maybe 2 in the whole last decade that were of the same standard.
Yeah, thats what I mean - I said it wrong.. I meant my recent favourite albums D:
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2011 11:28 pm
by efence
one of first electronica alblums i heard....still listen to it on my mp3 player

these 2 albums were the 2 that stand out for me wanting to expand my consciousness

Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 12:47 am
by Duffman
Can't believe I'm the first person to post this album!

This album was way ahead of it's time, and to me it still sounds ahead of its time! Nobody was properly experimenting with electronic sounds like Pink Floyd did on this album, especially them using the first sequencer in 'On the Run'. The album flows better than any other album I have ever heard and each track fading into the other seamlessly. It's perfect for all occasions, live or at home and most importantly sounds amazing on a proper system. The production and recording techniques used on this album are next to none and were some of the most advanced studio techniques of the time.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 1:58 am
by Basic A
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 3:30 am
by JBE
Duffman wrote:Can't believe I'm the first person to post this album!

This album was way ahead of it's time, and to me it still sounds ahead of its time! Nobody was properly experimenting with electronic sounds like Pink Floyd did on this album, especially them using the first sequencer in 'On the Run'. The album flows better than any other album I have ever heard and each track fading into the other seamlessly. It's perfect for all occasions, live or at home and most importantly sounds amazing on a proper system. The production and recording techniques used on this album are next to none and were some of the most advanced studio techniques of the time.
You weren't the first, I just didn't use images. I do agree though, it was a great album.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 6:31 am
by amphibian
Opiou - Slurp and Giggle.
Perfect in every fucking way. I also second Nirvana's nevermind. That album had a special spot with me in highschool. Then adam freeland fucked it.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 7:08 am
by travis_baker
Sigur ros- untitled, is my favorite and or black seeds-keep on pushing
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 10:29 am
by Duffman
JBE wrote:Duffman wrote:Can't believe I'm the first person to post this album!

This album was way ahead of it's time, and to me it still sounds ahead of its time! Nobody was properly experimenting with electronic sounds like Pink Floyd did on this album, especially them using the first sequencer in 'On the Run'. The album flows better than any other album I have ever heard and each track fading into the other seamlessly. It's perfect for all occasions, live or at home and most importantly sounds amazing on a proper system. The production and recording techniques used on this album are next to none and were some of the most advanced studio techniques of the time.
You weren't the first, I just didn't use images. I do agree though, it was a great album.
Must have missed yours, great choice though.
Imo there is no other perfect album, but some that come close are:

Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 10:34 am
by JBE
Duffman wrote:

That's a great album to. I haven't actually listened to it in awhile. I think I know what I'm doing when I get home.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 10:36 am
by murky21
with regard to a really simple definition in my book (this ain't everything but still...) if you have the urge to skip any tracks its not a perfect album. These albums should be listened to start to finish, with a perfect flow from track to track
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 10:37 am
by Duffman
JBE wrote:Duffman wrote:

That's a great album to. I haven't actually listened to it in awhile. I think I know what I'm doing when I get home.
Might do the same

Some of the best guitar work I have ever heard is on that album.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 11:13 am
by buttock

for Kyuss
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 1:13 pm
by mondays child
Nick Drake because it's an entirely listenable journey from start o finish, immaculate production
and instrumentation. And the lyrics are just as good.
This Bibio album because it's again, listenable all the way through and imparts
an almost 'journey' like feel to the whole thing, it's also got a nice 'underproduced' sound to it.
And this because it's a bomb of an album, that combines raw power with a solid intellectual message
direct from the streets.

Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 1:51 pm
by hudson
mondays child wrote:
Loooooove Nick Drake. He was so ahead of his time. Everyone I show him to (usually Pink Moon) can't believe he died 40 years ago.
Re: The definition of a perfect album.
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 2:16 pm
by Augment
Basic A wrote:
+1