Slothrop wrote:Kapital wrote:Another thing...I think sampling takes way more, let's say, "time & care". I go through my music, go through tracks....try and piece together loops. Try and manipulate loops to my own liking, and that becomes the foundation for a track more times.
I just two nights ago went into the preset bank in Massive...if cats choose that shit straight up, there is no real creativity involved. If you straight up click "Elephant Federation" and hold down g and let it do what it does, its in no way similar to carefully selected samples from musical sources. That's more like, I dunno, Madlib giving you his loops sans beats....get my drift?
To me it's not some sort of pissing contest about who can do the hardest thing, though. I like the idea of people being happy or moved or dancing and music in general being better because of the stuff I'm doing, and if I can do that better via taking a shortcut then I'll go for it.
There are long term problems that are going to come with
always taking the easy way and
always relying on the preset to write the tune for you - you end up with a scene that's limited by the preset designers rather than driven forward by the producers - but I wouldn't write it off straight out under all circumstances.
And to be honest, a lot of sounds are going to be generic whether you roll your own presets or not. I mean, some people might care whether the big evolving pad sound you used is entirely your own work, but if you're using a basic organ sound or a standard analogue style bass or whatever then worrying about whether it's a preset or not is like worrying about whether a guitarist made their own guitar.
In my situation, I don't worry about any sound being a straight preset. I just don't use straight presets . It's not even a competitive thing, because guaranteed more time than not my music remains personal listening...so maybe that's where shit differs for me. Whether people recognize the sound is carefully made or a preset isnt even a thought. And even if my shit was more in the public domain, and 85% of them couldnt catch the difference between preset or not, it's all about the personal satisfaction knowing my sound was that dope.
Also, I'm never thinking like, "Mr. Johnson" preset sounds like its gonna work on a dance-floor or whatever it may be. Building a patch should just be about having an interesting in learning how to make sound. If folks choose to get down to it, that's on them. That's the angle I approach this music shit from. Maybe it's a focus thing, cuz I'll make arbitrary beats based on whatever mood I'm in. It's not like I'm known to make dancefloor tunes and direct my sound towards a specific way...so I never feel compelled to go a certain route. Maybe that's a bad thing lol....dunno really.
I don't know if somebody already said this or not, but I find that when they list 50 presets or whatever; sure it's meant to be used...no question there, but it's more like telling people "if you actually try, your shit will sound this dope". I also don't think something like Massive can be truly "generic", maybe it is generic insofar as ppl arent creative and hijack the next mans style. I guess there's something like the low wobble where inevitably cats are gonna body that sound (to me it doesnt get old lol)...but I think as it is, with that synth you have a near unlimited ability to create the widest array of sounds. It's just how much willingness somebody has to not sound like 1 000 000 other producers.
Whatever though, from a home listening perspective, I don't listen to music and hate on tunes because I can identify a preset (well...depends)...if it's sick, then it's sick. But as one who likes to make music, I stay away from them. Plus, it's fuckin overwhelming....there's sooooo many to go through. I can see that in itself being frustrating.